Understanding Overeating and Removing Processed Foods from Your Diet

Understanding Overeating

Studying the precise impact of ultra-processed foods on overeating poses a challenge for scientists, as it necessitates meticulous control over individuals' diets for extended periods.

However, Dr. Kevin Hall, a metabolism researcher at the NIH, has conducted a study where he compared the effects of a highly processed diet to a minimally processed diet on calorie intake and weight gain. The study participants were placed in NIH's Metabolic Clinical Research Unit for a total of four weeks, with two weeks dedicated to each diet. Both diets provided the same daily amounts of calories, sugar, fiber, fat, sodium, and carbohydrates. During the study, participants had the freedom to consume as much or as little food as they desired.

Individuals consuming an ultra-processed diet exhibited an increased daily caloric intake of approximately 500 calories. Moreover, they experienced an average weight gain of approximately 2 pounds. Conversely, those following the less-processed diet demonstrated an average weight loss of approximately 2 pounds.

The variations in nutrient composition within the overall diet were not responsible for the disparities observed. Additionally, the participants reported that they found both diets equally enjoyable. Consequently, the precise reason behind the increased consumption of the diet consisting of ultra-processed foods remains uncertain to the researchers.

Hall's team is currently investigating the potential factors present in ultra-processed foods that contribute to excessive food consumption. It is possible that the brain responds differently to these foods, or that the gut releases distinct signals following their digestion.

The tendency for ultra-processed foods to lead to overeating may partly explain the recent rise in obesity.

“But we rely on ultra-processed foods too much to get rid of them,” Hall says. “They’re tasty, they’re convenient, and it doesn’t take much time or effort or skill to prepare them.”

Hall hopes that gaining a deeper comprehension of the factors contributing to the rise in calorie intake can serve as a valuable guideline for the production and selection of food options.

“If we had ways to target problematic foods by understanding how they cause overeating, that might help manufacturers reformulate those foods so that they no longer cause problems,” says Hall. “Or it might help policymakers come up with ways to regulate potentially problematic foods.”

Changes in the Brain

One potential mechanism through which ultra-processed foods could contribute to excessive food consumption is by affecting the brain. To investigate this, DiFeliceantonio and his team are employing MRI scans to examine the impact of ultra-processed foods on the brain's reward system, which encompasses regions associated with pleasure and the motivation to seek it. The objective of DiFeliceantonio's research is to determine whether a diet rich in ultra-processed foods influences this system, and if such alterations subsequently result in increased food intake when individuals are not experiencing hunger.

The potential relationship between the consumption of ultra-processed foods and an increased desire for them raises the question of whether addiction to these products is possible. Currently, there is no conclusive evidence regarding the addictive nature of ultra-processed foods. However, certain studies indicate a possible association between these foods and addictive behaviors.

“These ultra-processed, highly rewarding foods have way more in common with a cigarette than they do with an apple or an orange or black beans,” says Dr. Ashley Gearhardt, a clinical psychologist who studies overeating behaviors at the University of Michigan. “Some of the same brain circuitry turns on when we’re craving drugs as when we’re craving these ultra-processed foods.”

Gearhardt suggests that the consumption of ultra-processed foods could potentially result in the development of a compulsive behavior. This would manifest as a challenge in reducing consumption, even when an individual desires to do so. This phenomenon bears resemblance to the addictive patterns observed with substances that are known to be addictive.

Addictive substances can induce withdrawal symptoms upon cessation, which encompass irritability, agitation, depression, and intense cravings for the substance. In a similar vein, Gearhardt and other scientists are investigating the potential occurrence of comparable withdrawal symptoms when reducing consumption of ultra-processed foods. This line of research holds promise in understanding the difficulties certain individuals encounter when attempting to adopt healthier eating habits.

“Right now, we tell people they should feel better if they’re eating healthier,” Gearhardt says. “But we hear a lot of people say: ‘When I start to eat healthier, I feel so irritable and agitated. My cravings are so strong that I don’t feel better. I feel worse.’”

According to Gearhardt, implementing strategies to manage these symptoms could be beneficial in helping individuals to change their eating habits. Recognizing the occurrence of these symptoms would enable us to provide people with effective tools to address them. Consequently, this approach may contribute to a more seamless transition towards healthier eating behaviors.

Tips for a Healthier Diet

1. Choose Whole Foods: Opt for fruits, vegetables, unprocessed meats, seafood, nuts, and legumes.
2. Reduce Sugary Beverages: Cut down on soda and sports drinks.
3. Prioritize Whole Grains: Select foods made from whole grains rather than refined grains.
4. Keep Healthy Snacks Handy: Stock up on vegetables with hummus, fruits, low-fat yogurt, nuts, and seeds.
5. Read Nutrition Labels: Be informed about what you’re consuming.
6. Seek Support: Consider seeking guidance or support to maintain a balanced diet.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.